Prayer Oil - 24th Sunday after Pentecost

Prayer Oil - 24th Sunday after Pentecost

Author: Pastor Scott Schul
November 08, 2026

Jesus knew that in just a few days, everything would be turned upside down.  One of his friends would betray him.  He would be arrested, tried, tortured, and crucified.  Of course, that wouldn’t be the end of the story.  In his resurrection, all things would be made new again.  Yet nothing would ever be the same as it was.  Responsibility for guiding the Church here on earth would shift to people like Peter, who had already shown himself to be as uneven as a teeter-totter.  Now, more than ever before, it would be crucial for Jesus’s followers to be prepared or, to put it in the language of today’s parable, to have their oil lamps full.

That’s the context of this parable, which you may find perplexing.  Why didn’t the wise bridesmaids share some of their oil with the others?  They seem selfish.  Merciless.  And what about the bridegroom?  Did he really shut the door on the unwise bridesmaids?  And when they begged him to open it and admit them into the banquet, did he really refuse them, claiming he no longer knew them?  Where’s the grace in that?

So let’s pause for a moment and recall that Jesus intends his parables to provoke us, to get our attention, to even turn our worldview upside down.  The story lines and characters are memorable because they’re so exaggerated.  We misread the parables when we over-literalize them.  View them like an impressionist painting- up close it’s just a chaotic mess.  But step back, and the bigger picture suddenly becomes clear.

The key in this parable is to resist interpreting the oil as a commodity- a thing.  After all, no amount of literal lamp oil was going to ensure the survival of the Church once Jesus ascended to heaven.  And likewise, we know that mere things are not the currency of holiness.  We can’t buy our way or stockpile our way to heaven with an abundance of things.

But what if we think of the oil as a relationship?  What if we think of the oil as consistently being mindful of the bridegroom, prepared to be with the bridegroom, and always seeing the world and everyone in it through the lens of that relationship?  Now let’s make this even simpler and clearer.  What if we think of that oil, that relationship, as prayer?  After all, I can pray to God for your benefit, but I am incapable of saying your prayers for you.  I can’t give you that oil.  And I can ask God to stir a desire in you to pray more and have a closer relationship to God, but what you do with all that is between you and the bridegroom. Again, I can’t give you that oil. 

OK, but what about the ending, where the bridegroom, Jesus, refuses to open the door or even admit to knowing the unwise bridesmaids?  How do we make sense of that?  Would Jesus really do that?  Look, I dare to hope that everyone, without exception, will at some point find the love of Jesus to be irresistible and that no one will be left behind or denied a place at God’s table.  But Jesus isn’t going to forcibly drag any of us to heaven, kicking, screaming, and protesting.  Love doesn’t compel.   Love persuades.  But eventually the time for persuasion will come to an end.

Jesus is using the hyperbole of this parable to force each of us to candidly, frankly, honestly, assess the state of our oil.  Stated more directly, consider your faith life, your prayer life, and your overall relationship with Jesus.  Is he truly the Lord of your life, or is he somewhere lower in your Top 20 list?  That leads us to the critical question this parable asks: If your oil supply is low, what are you waiting for?  After all, nothing in the parable  suggests that the unwise bridesmaids didn’t have time to get oil or that they didn’t know where to buy it.  They just got busy.  They just got distracted.  And at some point, they just ran out of time.  What about you?  When it comes to having the sort of faith life, worship life, and prayer life you deep down desire, what’s holding you back?  What are you waiting for?

I do a lot of thinking about prayer, largely because I want and need a fuller, richer prayer life.  I suspect you’re in the same boat.  So in the remainder of this sermon I’ll share three ideas or counsels with you to help you pray.  Let’s begin with the one thing other than the weather that we talk about all the time.  “I’m so busy.  How am I supposed to find time to get my oil, to pray, when I have so many other things bearing down on me?” 

This isn’t a phenomenon unique to our present day and age.  Way back in 1535, Martin Luther observed in a letter to a friend that it’s best to make prayer your “first business of the morning and the last at night.”  He wrote, “Guard yourself carefully against those false, deluding ideas which tell you, ‘Wait a little while.  I will pray in an hour; first I must attend to this or that.’  Such thoughts get you away from prayer into other affairs which so hold your attention and involve you that nothing comes of prayer for that day.”1  So my first counsel to you on prayer is this: Schedule prayer first and arrange the rest of your day around prayer.  You know as well as I do that when we try to fit prayer into those rare little openings in our schedule, we seldom end up praying.  After all, there’s always time to get the oil later, right?  That’s what we tell ourselves.  But the parable knows better.  So schedule prayer first.  Then schedule the rest of your day.  Not only because God wants us to pray, but because our spirits need prayer as much as our bodies need food and water. 

My second counsel to you on this holy oil we call prayer is this: don’t overcomplicate it.  Have you ever desired to take up a hobby, like woodworking, golf, knitting, or playing piano, and decided you first needed to study up on it?  Before long, you lose the wonder of being a dabbler and get immersed in the intricacies of expertise, at least intellectually, and become so intimidated and overwhelmed that you give up before you start.  That happens with prayer too.  So keep prayer simple!

Robert Llewelyn was a gentle little Anglican priest who died in 2008.  He wrote a few small books on spirituality that I treasure.  Listen to how he defined prayer.  He wrote, “Prayer is waiting, intending, desiring God.  Prayer, we might say, is a holding on to God, until waiting, waiting, waiting, we move into the knowledge that we are being held.”2  Isn’t that beautiful?  That’s prayer!  So be present with God.  Wait with God.  How is less important.  Do it with silence.  Do it with the words of a prayer book.  Do it with your own words, spontaneously spoken from the depths of your heart.  Do it with praise.  Do it with joy.  Do it with lament.  Do it with anger.  Do it with puzzlement.  Just don’t let form get in the way of function.  Hold onto God and wait, wait, wait until you realize you are being held.

The third and final counsel on prayer that I’ll offer you (at least today) comes from one of my dearest theological guides, a 14th century English woman known to us as Julian of Norwich.  In Chapter 43 of her famous revelations, Julian wrote, “Prayer ‘oneth’ the soul to God.”  “Oneth” is a lovely ancient Middle English word that means “unites” or “makes us one.”  That’s important because though we’ve been created in God’s image, sin has distorted that image.  And so we pray to be “oneth” to God.  United with God.  Made one with God.  In so doing, we become our true selves again.  We can breathe again.  We can be truly human again.

Friends, Peter and the disciples are long gone.  Jesus has now entrusted the Church and the world’s healing to us.  So now, more than ever before, it’s crucial that we have full oil lamps.  Jesus, our bridegroom is coming, and the very good news is he loves us dearly and wants us at a banquet so grand it will last for eternity.  So for our own sake, for the world’s sake, let’s not delay.  While there’s time, let’s get our oil.  Amen.

© 2026 Rev. Scott E. Schul, all rights reserved

Citations:
1 Luther’s Works Vol. 47, p. 193 (American Edition, © 1968 Fortress Press).
2 Robert Llewelyn, Why Pray?, p. 27-28 (© 2019 Paraclete Press).

Gospel Text: Matthew 25:1-13

[Jesus said to the disciples:] 1 “Then the kingdom of heaven will be like this. Ten young women took their lamps and went to meet the bridegroom. 2 Five of them were foolish, and five were wise. 3 When the foolish took their lamps, they took no oil with them, 4 but the wise took flasks of oil with their lamps. 5 As the bridegroom was delayed, all of them became drowsy and slept. 6 But at midnight there was a shout, ‘Look! Here is the bridegroom! Come out to meet him.’ 7 Then all those young women got up and trimmed their lamps. 8 The foolish said to the wise, ‘Give us some of your oil, for our lamps are going out.’ 9 But the wise replied, ‘No! there will not be enough for you and for us; you had better go to the dealers and buy some for yourselves.’ 10 And while they went to buy it, the bridegroom came, and those who were ready went with him into the wedding banquet, and the door was shut. 11 Later the other young women came also, saying, ‘Lord, lord, open to us.’ 12 But he replied, ‘Truly I tell you, I do not know you.’ 13 Keep awake, therefore, for you know neither the day nor the hour.”

 


BACK

Grace Lutheran Church & Preschool
205 South Garner Street, State College, PA 16801
(814) 238-2478


Church Office Hours
8am-3 pm Mon-Thurs
8-Noon Friday (September 1- May 31)
8-Noon Mon-Friday (June1-August 31)




Contact Church Contact Preschool

Top